In 18th century Japan, society is ruled by the ettiquette set by the Imperial
Shogun. When a young lord refuses to become involved with a corrupt chancellor,
his lands are forfeited and his samurai disbanded. The samurai are torn between
orders from the Shogun and loyalty to their lord. 47 Ronin (Chushingura) is a
true classic of Japanese cinema.
The 47 Ronin / Chushingura Movie Review
By DVD Verdict
"Chushingura is director Hiroshi Inagaki's take on the tale of 47 loyal
ronin who plot revenge on the man who orchestrated their master's death. The
story of Chushingura is so popular in Japan, Inagaki's is roughly the fifth
(and most famous) version released in the thirty years spanning
1932 to 1962.
…The logical question to ask is, how does it compare with Seven Samurai
or other films by Akira Kurosawa, Japanese films with which a western audience
is likely to be more familiar? Well, Chushingura is more purely Japanese. Honor,
ceremonial propriety, and group identity are central in the world of
Chushingura, a world in which the Shogunate is still strong and exerting
enormous top-down social influence. In other words, Chushingura is very
specifically culturally Japanese; one's knowledge of feudal Japan will affect
one's understanding and enjoyment of the film. It's hard to imagine Kurosawa
making a film that takes place in the same period as Chushingura, or making his
own version of Chushingura. Kurosawa is more fascinated with periods of civil
war, periods in which rigid social strictures have broken down and individuals
are unmoored from their old roles, their old duties. The ronin of Seven Samurai
are caught between two worlds; the film ends with their acknowledgement that
they can't regain the world they've lost and they will never find a place in the
new world with which they're confronted.
So, is Chushingura any good? Hell, yes. I don't want to give a wrong
impression. One doesn't have to hold a post-graduate degree in Japanese history
to enjoy the film. I certainly don't. On many levels, it's a fun adventure
film. It tends to be a little more David Lean than Kurosawa in its fascination
with long shots of beautiful scenery (there's certainly nothing wrong with
that; Lawrence Of Arabia would probably be right after Seven Samurai on my list
of favorite films). It's often (annoyingly) referred to as Japan's Gone with
the Wind, and its pacing is very similar, slow but deliberate with much of the
intrigue centered in interaction between characters rather than swordplay.
Hiroshi Inagaki knows how to make a good film; among his body of work is the
epic Samurai trilogy, based on the life of the master swordsman Miyamoto Musashi
and starring the most famous actor in Japanese film history, and frequent
Kurosawa collaborator, Toshiro Mifune. Trust me, when you watch this film,
you're in good hands…"