In this book, Gary Taubes argues that the ‘calories in and calories out’
and ‘fat is evil’ doctrines upon which obesity management practices in the
medical industry are founded are nothing more than myths borne out of faulty
research, prejudice i.e. Fat people are fat because they are gluttons and sloths
and the wrong people having too much influence on nutritional policies in
America. And how early European researchers were actually more on track because
their work suggested obesity as a disorder of fat storage and accumulation.
Taubes, a science writer, is writer first and a ‘scientist’ second. This is
evident in a couple of flaws in his position. Taubes argues that carbohydrates
are evil; he doesn't distinct between refined starchy evils like white bread and
wholesome starches like kumara. As other obesity researchers have pointed out
there are healthy and lean tribes of people that live on a high starch diet.
Secondly, Taubes omits to mention leptin, a hormone produced by fat tissue and
is important in informing the brain when fat storages are ‘full’ so that the
brain can reduce appetite and increase the metabolic rate. Other than that, a
brilliant mind broadening read. If you wish to take ownership of your own
knowledge of health matters including the subject of obesity, and not leave it
in the hands of your GP, I suggest you get yourself a copy of this book.