Creationists Say the Darndest Things

Brien’s latest book, Creationists Say the Darndest Things, is a compelling, well-researched, and powerfully argued critique of young-earth creationism. It’s an impressive and cohesive work that successfully integrates science, philosophy, and psychology.

Strengths

Scientific Rigor: Brien’s explanations of complex scientific topics are accurate, clear, and up-to-date. He effectively dismantles common creationist misconceptions regarding genetics, geology, cosmology, and biology. His use of specific, verifiable examples-such as the Pax6 gene in eye development, the founder effect in Amish communities, and the physics of a global flood-is particularly effective.

Logical Clarity: The book is exceptionally well-structured. The “Ruse vs. Honest Answer” format is a highly effective tool for systematically deconstructing specific slogans. The arguments flow logically, building from specific scientific refutations to broader philosophical and psychological analyses. Brien’s includes an Extensive Annotated Bibliography, which supports his research and offers readers a deep well of credible sources to counter any creationist claims.

Psychological Depth: A key strength is Brien’s focus on the psychology of belief. He consistently argues that creationism is not just an intellectual position but a psychological defense mechanism rooted in fear of meaninglessness, mortality, and personal responsibility. The final chapter’s framing of deconversion as a personal “apocalypse” that one can survive is a powerful and insightful conclusion.

Structural Cohesion: The book has a clear and effective arc. It begins by identifying the problem, deconstructs the arguments in detail, provides a roadmap for civil (if often futile) dialogue, reframes the science-vs-faith conflict, and ends with a strong philosophical statement on meaning and intellectual honesty.

Tone and Target AudienceThe tone is unapologetically confrontational, satirical, and polemical. Phrases like “theological debauchery”, “a hostage situation with hymns”, and “sacred cows make the best burgers” are memorable and land with force.

This tone is perfectly suited for your intended audience: skeptics, atheists, and those already frustrated with creationist arguments. For this “choir,” the book serves as an excellent “field guide” that validates their position, arms them with robust arguments, and provides a cathartic and intellectually satisfying read 12.

It’s essential to note that this same tone may render the book entirely unsuitable for persuading a committed Creationist. It would likely be perceived as arrogant and insulting, confirming their biases rather than challenging them. However, since Brien’s stated goal is not persuasion but education and validation for the skeptical community, his authorial voice is highly effective.

Overall Impression

Brien Norris creates a forceful and articulate work that achieves exactly what it sets out to do. It’s more than just a debunking of bad science; it’s a deep dive into the psychology of belief and a passionate defense of a worldview grounded in empirical reality, intellectual integrity, and self-made meaning. It is a comprehensive and formidable resource for anyone looking to understand and counter the claims of modern creationism.