Angie and her friends have been given clues-left by Angie's ancestor, Evangeline-that could lead them to Blackbeard's famous treasure. Angie is guided to her true love by Evangeline, whose spirit has wandered the shores of Ocracoke Island, searching for her lost love. The soulmates are reunited after Angie and Thomas discover the lost heart pendant that leads them toward a never-ending romance. Angie is left wondering if soulmates can pass from one lifetime to another. Angie and her friends embark upon a cryptic adventure to a tropical island in the Bahamas to search for the pirate booty. In a surprise twist, along the way, they stumble upon information that could lead them to solve the mystery of the disappearance of the Lost Colonists of Roanoke Island. They are determined to solve the two mysteries, despite grave danger. In a saga marked by love, romance, and peril, will the warnings from Evangeline and other spirits from the long-ago past be enough to keep Angie and her friends safe?